Oracle Java Licensing Changes Timeline

Oracle Java licensing has evolved significantly over recent years. Understanding this timeline can help organizations manage licensing effectively, avoid compliance issues, and control costs.

Here’s a clear breakdown of the key changes, their implications, and actionable insights for businesses.

Early Java Licensing: Free and Unrestricted Usage (Until 2019)

Oracle’s Java licensing was relatively simple until 2019:

• Java SE was provided under the Binary Code License (BCL).
• This license allowed free usage, including commercial environments, without strict enforcement.
• Oracle regularly provided public updates and patches at no cost.

Due to this open model, businesses widely adopted Oracle Java. IT teams and developers benefited from ease of access and minimal licensing concerns.

Shift to Subscription Licensing (2019)

In January 2019, Oracle fundamentally changed its Java licensing strategy:

• Ended the availability of public updates for Java SE 8 for commercial use without a subscription.
• Introduced the Oracle Java SE Subscription model, requiring commercial users to pay for access to ongoing support and updates.

Key changes included:

• Java SE Subscription: Payments are required for ongoing patches, security updates, and support for Java SE 8 and later.
• End of Free Updates: After January 2019, Oracle stopped providing free public updates for commercial users of Java SE 8.
• Compliance Audits: Oracle started stricter enforcement, making license audits more frequent for businesses using Java commercially without subscriptions.

What Triggered This Change?

• Oracle aimed to monetize its widespread Java user base.
• Increased focus on recurring subscription revenue over free software distribution.
• Oracle’s aggressive audits motivated organizations to quickly adapt to subscription licensing.

Impact on Businesses:

• Immediate licensing costs for previously free software will increase.
• Increased complexity of managing Java license compliance.
• Organizations need to audit their internal Java deployments to avoid compliance risks.

Introduction of NFTC License for Java 17+ (2021)

In September 2021, Oracle released Java 17 under the No-Fee Terms and Conditions (NFTC) license.

Key Points of the NFTC License:

• Allowed free usage for Java 17+ versions in production and commercial environments.
• Included access to security patches and updates for a limited time (usually until the next Long-Term Support (LTS) version is released).
• Eliminated immediate licensing costs but did not provide long-term assurance of free support.

Implications for Organizations:

• Short-term Savings: Companies could temporarily avoid subscription costs.
• Limited Updates: Once the next Java LTS version (e.g., Java 21) launches, Oracle typically stops providing free updates for Java 17, prompting businesses to either upgrade or revert to subscriptions.
• Complex Licensing Management: Companies faced uncertainty about future licensing costs and upgrade requirements.

Employee-Based Licensing Model (2023)

Oracle made another major shift in January 2023 by moving toward an employee-based licensing model:

• Oracle introduced the Oracle Java SE Universal Subscription.
• Licensing moved from server- or named user-based models to an employee-based subscription.
• Companies must pay licenses based on total employee count, regardless of Java usage.

Understanding the Employee-Based Model:

Practical Implications:

• Cost Increase for Large Organizations: Businesses with large employee bases but limited Java usage face steep cost increases.
• Simplicity for Some: Smaller organizations using Java extensively across all departments might find this model simpler, albeit expensive.
• Licensing Compliance: Oracle simplified audits because the license metric (total employees) is easier to verify.

Example Scenario:

A global manufacturing company with 10,000 employees and Java applications on only 10 servers previously paid based on those servers or specific users. After the 2023 change, the company must pay licensing fees based on 10,000 employees, significantly increasing licensing expenses.

Key Challenges and Insights for Businesses

Oracle’s frequent licensing changes create continuous compliance challenges.

Here are essential strategies businesses should consider:

Proactive License Management

• Regularly audit and document Java deployments.
• Maintain accurate records of Java versions in use and their licenses.
• Utilize software asset management (SAM) tools to track deployments accurately.

Example: A multinational bank implements an automated SAM tool that continuously monitors Java versions and license compliance, avoiding audit risks.

Strategic Version Selection

• Evaluate the financial and operational impact of staying on older Java versions versus upgrading regularly.
• Carefully plan Java version upgrades around Oracle’s release schedule and licensing changes.

Example: A mid-sized software firm strategically chooses Java 17 for initial cost savings under NFTC but prepares early for eventual upgrades to subsequent LTS versions.

Alternative Java Distributions

• Consider using alternative free Java distributions, such as OpenJDK, Amazon Corretto, Azul Zulu, or Eclipse Temurin.
• Assess whether your software and applications are compatible with these alternatives.

Comparison of Java Alternatives:

Example: A media company switched from Oracle Java to Amazon Corretto, reducing licensing fees and securing reliable long-term support.

Conclusion and Recommendations

Oracle’s Java licensing evolution has shifted from free, unrestricted access to tightly managed and monetized subscription models:

• Before 2019: Free Java for all.
• 2019: Subscription required for commercial users.
• 2021: Reprieve with Java 17 NFTC.
• 2023: Universal employee-based subscription, significantly impacting licensing costs.

Organizations should:

• Regularly audit their Java usage.
• Stay informed about Oracle licensing changes.
• Consider alternative Java distributions to control costs.
• Invest in proactive licensing management to avoid compliance pitfalls.

Staying ahead of Oracle’s licensing adjustments is crucial for effectively managing IT budgets, maintaining compliance, and avoiding costly audits.

Do you want to know more about our Java Advisory Services?

Please enable JavaScript in your browser to complete this form.

Name *

Email *

Company

Message *

Submit