How Third-Party Software Impacts Your Java License Requirements
Many enterprises are discovering hidden Java licensing obligations tied to the third-party software they use.
Oracle’s licensing changes mean that if your business applications run on Java, you must determine whether the software vendor covers the Java license or if you need a separate Oracle Java subscription yourself.
This advisory explains when embedded Java is covered under another product’s license versus when you are responsible for licensing Java – and what to do about it.
Hidden Java Licensing Risk in Third-Party Software
Oracle’s recent Java licensing changes have turned Java into a potential compliance risk and budget item for many companies.
Insight: Enterprise IT and procurement teams often overlook that a third-party application running on Java might quietly trigger an Oracle Java license requirement.
For years, Java was free for general use, so many organizations embedded Oracle’s Java Runtime Environment (JRE) in various tools without concern.
Now, however, running Oracle Java in production requires a paid subscription unless an exception applies. This shift has left some firms facing surprise costs.
Real-world example: Imagine a global company using a popular data analytics tool that runs on Java. They installed Oracle’s JRE on their servers to support this tool back when Java was free.
During a routine audit, Oracle’s team identified the Java installations and presented a substantial bill based on the company’s total employee count, even though only a fraction of employees actually used the Java-based tool.
In one case, an organization with thousands of employees but limited Java usage still received an unexpected seven-figure demand due to Oracle’s new licensing model, which is tied to headcount.
Practical takeaway:
Treat Java like any other commercial software in your license management. Inventory all applications that include or require Java, especially third-party and internally developed systems.
Determine whether each Java instance is properly licensed. Failing to do so can mean either paying for licenses you didn’t need or facing compliance issues and back-charges during an audit.
The key is to identify those hidden Java deployments now, before Oracle does.
When Vendor Licenses cover embedded Java
Not all Java usage will cost you extra – in certain cases, the Java runtime is “bundled” or covered by the product vendor’s license.
Insight: Some software vendors (including Oracle itself) provide a Java license as part of their product, allowing you to use Java within that product’s scope without a separate Oracle Java subscription.
This typically happens with large vendors who have OEM or royalty agreements for Java.
Oracle’s products are the prime example. If you’re using an Oracle product that relies on Java, the Oracle product license usually includes rights to Java for that usage.
For instance, Oracle WebLogic Server and Oracle E-Business Suite both run on Java. If you are properly licensed for those products (and paying support), you are entitled to use the Java platform embedded in them for the product’s functionality.
You do not need to buy a separate Oracle Java SE license to run Oracle software that includes Java; it’s essentially part of the product entitlement.
The same goes for components like Oracle Database or Oracle’s middleware: the Java needed to run the database or middleware is covered under your Oracle product agreement, but only for that purpose.
A few non-Oracle vendors have also arranged similar deals.
Real-world example: Adobe’s ColdFusion application server historically bundles Oracle’s Java. Adobe secured a distribution agreement that allows ColdFusion customers to use Oracle Java (JDK 8, JDK 11, etc.) for running ColdFusion without contracting directly with Oracle.
In practice, ColdFusion users download Java from Adobe and abide by Oracle’s terms. Still, Adobe’s license coverage means the end customer isn’t required to purchase an Oracle Java subscription for that usage.
Likewise, a handful of other major software makers, such as IBM and SAP, had special OEM arrangements or provided their own Java implementations, thereby shielding their customers from Oracle licensing fees for using Java with those particular applications.
Practical takeaway:
Always confirm with your software vendor whether Java is included in your product license. Don’t assume – check your license agreements or ask the vendor’s support team for confirmation.
If the contract explicitly states that an “Oracle Java SE” license is included for use with the application, you’re in the clear for that specific use.
When in doubt, get clarification in writing. This due diligence ensures you either capitalize on any “free” Java usage rights included with a product or budget for Java licenses where needed.
When You Need a Separate Oracle Java Subscription
In the majority of cases, using Java with third-party or in-house applications will require you to obtain your own Java license.
Insight: Most independent software vendors do not cover Oracle Java in their license agreements.
They may require Java to run their software, but they typically expect the customer to provide a Java runtime environment. In the past, that wasn’t an issue because Oracle’s Java was free to use.
Now that Oracle mandates a subscription for commercial Java use (for versions and scenarios not covered by Oracle’s free terms), the responsibility lands on you as the end user.
Real-world scenario:
Consider a procurement team deploying a third-party CRM system that runs on Java. The vendor’s documentation recommends installing Java, but makes no mention of providing a license.
After 2019, if the IT team simply downloads Oracle JDK and uses it to run this CRM in production, the company is technically required to have an Oracle Java SE subscription for that deployment. If they don’t, they’re out of compliance.
Many open-source applications and smaller vendor tools fall into this category – they need Java but provide no license for it, and historically, everyone just used Oracle’s JRE.
Now, this practice can lead to compliance gaps. During an audit or contract renewal, Oracle can identify these unlicensed Java instances (through download records or usage reports) and demand retroactive fees.
Practical takeaway: Assume you need to license Java for any software that the vendor doesn’t explicitly cover. Suppose your application vendor hasn’t stated that they have an Oracle Java distribution license (and most haven’t).
In that case, you have two choices: purchase Oracle Java subscriptions to cover those installations, or switch to an alternative Java runtime (such as OpenJDK or another vendor’s build) that doesn’t require Oracle licenses.
Many enterprises are now standardizing on open-source Java distributions for both third-party and internal applications to avoid unexpected fees.
The bottom line is that if Java is running in production for your organization’s business processes and no vendor is backing it with a license, it’s your responsibility to address the licensing – either through Oracle or via an alternative solution.
Oracle’s Java Licensing Model Changes and Cost Implications
Oracle’s Java SE licensing has evolved from a targeted, usage-based model to a broad subscription model, which can significantly impact costs.
Insight: Originally, Oracle offered Java SE subscriptions on a per-user or per-processor basis, allowing companies to license only the specific Java usage they required.
In 2023, Oracle transitioned to a Java SE Universal Subscription model, which requires licensing based on the total number of employees in the organization.
This change can dramatically increase costs for enterprises that only use Java in limited areas but have a large workforce.
To understand the difference, consider the legacy model versus the new model:
| Aspect | Legacy Java SE Licensing (pre-2023) | New Java SE Universal Subscription (2023+) |
|---|---|---|
| Licensing Metric | Per Named User Plus (per user) or per Processor (per server core) | Per Employee (every employee and contractor in the company) |
| Coverage Scope | Only the licensed users or specific servers are covered | All Java usage enterprise-wide is covered once all employees are licensed |
| Cost Basis | ~$30 per user/year or ~$300 per processor/year | ~$180 per employee/year (with tiered volume discounts for large orgs) |
| Cost Scalability | Scales with actual Java use (number of users or servers running Java) | Scales with organization size (headcount), not actual usage |
| Renewal Flexibility | Could true-up or reduce licenses based on need; old model renewals were allowed through 2022 | No partial licensing – must license entire workforce; non-renewal triggers compliance scrutiny |
Under the old metrics, a company could buy, for example, 100 user licenses for Java or a few processor licenses for specific servers. Costs aligned with usage.
Under the new employee-based model, the same company must now license all employees (e.g., 5,000 employees * $180/year = $ 900,000/year), regardless of how few use Java.
This model simplifies compliance (one license covers any Java installations), but often raises costs exponentially for companies with limited Java needs.
Real-world example:
Many organizations have reported sticker shock when renewing their Java licenses.
A mid-sized firm that paid around $ 50,000 per year under the old model was quoted several hundred thousand dollars per year under the employee model, an increase of around 1,000%.
Even some larger enterprises, which were comfortable with Oracle’s previous pricing, found that the new terms would charge them for every employee in the company, making Java one of their largest IT subscription costs overnight.
Practical takeaway:
Understand the impact of the new Java licensing model on your budget. If you’re still on an older Java subscription, plan for the switch to employee-based licensing at renewal and model the cost based on the full headcount.
This may justify efforts to reduce your reliance on Oracle’s Java. If you have a Java renewal negotiation coming up, use the cost difference as leverage – Oracle knows the new pricing is a tough pill to swallow, so be prepared to push back or explore alternatives.
The Renewal Dilemma: Negotiating or Exiting Oracle Java
With the universal subscription model, every Oracle Java renewal becomes a strategic decision point. Insight: Oracle often uses renewals (or lack thereof) to enforce its new model and maximize revenue.
Suppose you choose not to renew an Oracle Java subscription. In that case, it’s effectively a red flag: Oracle will likely inquire (or audit) to ensure you have completely stopped using Oracle Java in your environment.
On the other hand, if you proceed with renewal, you may be locked into paying for far more than you use. Enterprise buyers must navigate between compliance and cost, and consider when it might be best to walk away from Oracle Java entirely.
Real-world example:
A large enterprise with a legacy Java agreement faced a renewal in 2024. Oracle informed them that their old per-processor licenses could not be extended; they had to transition to an employee-based model, which would incur annual costs of millions.
The company’s CIO was unwilling to accept a 10x budget increase without exploring options. They engaged a third-party support provider and began migrating critical systems to OpenJDK (the open-source Java).
Armed with this plan, they went back to Oracle. Ultimately, Oracle substantially discounted its proposal in an attempt to retain the business, and the company still decided to license only a small portion of its estate and shift the rest to the free OpenJDK.
In another case, a firm that simply let its Java subscription lapse without a replacement strategy quickly received an audit notice from Oracle, leading to a tense negotiation and a settlement for back licensing fees.
Practical takeaway:
Develop a Java renewal strategy well in advance of your contract expiration to ensure a smooth transition.
If you intend to stick with Oracle (for example, if you need their support for certain applications), enter negotiations with a clear picture of your actual Java usage. Push for concessions like volume discounts, price locks, or accounting for non-employee Java users only.
If Oracle’s terms are unpalatable, plan an exit: migrate applications to OpenJDK or other Java distributions, and do it before your Oracle contract ends.
Many organizations find that switching to open-source Java or third-party supported Java (from providers such as Azul, Amazon Corretto, IBM Semeru, etc.) can significantly reduce costs and eliminate Oracle’s compliance threat.
Ensure that if you drop Oracle’s subscription, you truly remove or replace all Oracle JDK installations and document this so you can certify compliance.
Whether negotiating a renewal or exiting, start early and involve your stakeholders (IT, procurement, legal) to weigh the risks and trade-offs.
Recommendations
1. Inventory All Java Usage: Maintain an up-to-date inventory of every system (servers, VMs, desktops) running Java. Include which applications or third-party software rely on that Java. This is the foundation for any licensing decision.
2. Confirm Vendor Coverage: For each commercial software in your estate, verify if the vendor provides a Java license. Review contracts and user guides; contact vendors directly for clarification. Keep written proof (e.g., an email or license clause) of any vendor-provided Java rights.
3. Use OpenJDK Where Possible: Avoid Oracle Java SE where you don’t explicitly need it. Transition to open-source Java (OpenJDK or builds like Eclipse Temurin, Amazon Corretto, etc.) for internal and third-party apps. This sidesteps Oracle licensing fees while still allowing you to run your applications on Java.
4. Segment Oracle Java to Essential Uses: If certain systems must use Oracle’s Java (perhaps for support or certification reasons), isolate those. Use Oracle Java only where necessary, so you minimize the scope (and cost) of Oracle licensing.
5. Engage in Early Renewal Planning: Don’t wait until a Java subscription is about to expire. Begin discussions 6-12 months in advance. Evaluate your usage vs. the cost of Oracle’s employee-based model. This lead time lets you test alternatives or negotiate from a position of knowledge.
6. Negotiate Contract Protections: If you must sign an Oracle Java agreement, negotiate terms to protect your organization. For example, seek a price cap on renewals, the right to reduce counts if your employee numbers drop, and removal of any onerous auto-renewal clauses. Aim for flexibility in case your Java needs change.
7. Monitor Oracle’s Licensing Updates: Oracle’s policies on Java can evolve. Assign someone to monitor communications from Oracle or updates to Java licensing terms. Being informed will enable you to react quickly to any changes that may affect your compliance.
8. Educate and Involve Stakeholders: Ensure your developers, IT operations, and procurement teams know about the Java licensing rules. An innocuous download of Oracle JDK by a developer could lead to compliance exposure. Build awareness so that using Oracle Java is always a conscious, approved decision.
Checklist: 5 Actions to Take
- Identify All Java-Dependent Applications: Run a discovery across your environment to list every application (commercial or custom) that requires Java. Include version details and specify the location where Java is installed.
- Classify License Coverage: For each application, determine if another license covers Java. Review vendor contracts and documentation for mentions of “Java SE” or “Oracle Java.” If unclear, formally ask the vendor about your Java licensing obligations.
- Assess Alternatives for Each Use Case: For any Java installation not covered by a vendor, decide whether to purchase an Oracle Java subscription or replace it. Evaluate moving that application to OpenJDK or another no-cost Java distribution. Test compatibility in a staging environment.
- Execute Migration or Licensing Plan: If you opt to migrate off Oracle Java, create a timeline and migrate those systems (e.g., deploy OpenJDK and uninstall Oracle JDK) before any audit or renewal deadlines. If you opt to license, consolidate the needed installations and purchase the appropriate Oracle Java SE subscriptions (or the new Universal Subscription) in line with your usage.
- Document and Continuously Govern: Keep detailed records of the actions you take – including contracts that cover Java, confirmation emails from vendors, and proof of Java uninstalls or OpenJDK deployments. Update your IT asset management records to flag where Oracle Java is used. Implement a governance policy that requires any new use of Java to be reviewed for licensing impact. This ongoing discipline will help you confidently face Oracle or any auditor and avoid surprises.
FAQ
Q1: If we use a third-party software that runs on Java, do we need an Oracle Java license?
A: In most cases, yes. Unless the software vendor explicitly provides a licensed Oracle Java as part of their product, you are responsible for licensing Java. A few vendors (for example, some Oracle products and a handful of others, such as Adobe ColdFusion) include Java rights for use with their applications. For anything else, running Oracle’s Java in production will require your company to have a Java SE subscription or an alternative in place.
Q2: How can we tell if an application vendor has covered the Java license for us?
A: Check the software’s license agreement or product documentation. Look for clauses about “third-party components” or specifically “Java SE.” If it says the product includes Oracle Java or that the vendor has a Java license on your behalf, then you’re covered when using Java for that application. You can also reach out to the vendor’s support or account rep – they should be familiar with how Java is licensed for their product. Always get the confirmation in writing for your audit files.
Q3: Is switching to OpenJDK difficult, and is it truly free to use?
A: OpenJDK is the open-source implementation of Java, and it’s free to use under an open-source license. It’s essentially the same codebase as Oracle’s Java (Oracle’s JDK is built on OpenJDK). Many organizations have successfully switched to OpenJDK or distributions like Azul Zulu, Amazon Corretto, or Eclipse Temurin with minimal disruption – these are drop-in replacements for Oracle JDK. The switch involves testing your applications with the new JDK to ensure compatibility, then updating your Java installations. In most cases, it’s straightforward. The key difference is that you may not have a single vendor, such as Oracle, to call for support; however, third-party support options are available for OpenJDK if needed. This approach can eliminate Oracle licensing costs while maintaining smooth operation of your Java applications.
Q4: What happens if we choose not to renew our Oracle Java subscription?
A: If you decide not to renew, you must stop using Oracle Java covered by that subscription by the end of the term. That typically means uninstalling Oracle JDK/JRE from all systems or replacing it with an alternative before your subscription expires. Oracle closely monitors non-renewals – they often reach out to organizations that let their subscriptions lapse, as it signals that they might still be running Java without a license. Be prepared for Oracle to inquire or even audit your environment. To protect yourself, ensure that by the time your contract ends, either you have completely transitioned to non-Oracle Java platforms or you have ceased using Java on those systems. Document everything (like verification of OpenJDK deployments) so you can demonstrate compliance. In short, non-renewal is viable, but only if accompanied by a complete migration away from Oracle’s Java.
Q5: How can we negotiate a better deal if we do need an Oracle Java subscription?
A: Go into discussions with Oracle armed with data and a plan. First, know your actual Java usage – how many servers, applications, and users truly require Oracle Java. Oracle’s default proposal will be the costly employee-wide model, but if your real usage is smaller, use that fact to seek a more reasonable scope or price. Highlight any steps you’re willing to take to reduce usage (Oracle may offer concessions to keep you as a customer rather than see you migrate everything to OpenJDK). You should also ask for volume-based discounts and price protections, such as committing to a multi-year term in exchange for a lower per-employee rate or capping annual price increases. If your employee count is near a tier breakpoint, consider negotiating to move into the lower tier. Additionally, consider aligning the Java negotiation with any larger Oracle deals (like database or cloud renewals) – sometimes Oracle is more flexible on Java pricing if it helps secure other business. Always obtain any negotiated terms in writing, and ensure your contract contains no surprises (such as onerous audit rights beyond the standard). By demonstrating that you have options and a deep understanding of your needs, you can often significantly improve the terms.
Read more about our Java Advisory Services.
