Oracle Java Licensing Changes 2023

The Java SE Subscription model is Oracle’s licensing framework for Java:

• Subscription-Based: Charges a monthly fee per user or processor.
• Comprehensive Coverage: Includes Java SE licensing, performance enhancements, updates, and Oracle Premier Support.
• Flexible Access: Provides access to Java SE commercial features, tools for monitoring, and management capabilities.
• Employee-Based Pricing: Recently shifted to charging based on the total company employee count, not just Java users.

Oracle Java Licensing Changes 2023

Oracle’s Java licensing changes in 2023 introduced a new subscription model that bases costs on the total number of employees rather than specific Java users or processors. The “Java SE Universal Subscription” requires organizations to license all employees who use Oracle’s Java, resulting in significantly higher costs for many enterprises.

IT leaders must understand these changes to avoid unexpected budget impacts and explore strategies (like alternative Java distributions or negotiations) to manage compliance and costs effectively.

What Changed in Oracle Java Licensing (2023)

In January 2023, Oracle overhauled its Java SE licensing model. The legacy Java SE subscriptions (which used to be licensed per Named User Plus for desktops or per Processor for servers) were replaced by a single Employee-based metric called the Java SE Universal Subscription.

In practical terms, if an organization uses Oracle’s Java (Oracle JDK) in any capacity, it now needs to purchase subscriptions for the entire employee headcount.

This represents a significant shift from the previous model, which only counted actual Java users or installations.

Oracle positioned the change as a simplification – one subscription covering use on desktops, servers, and cloud – but it effectively expands the chargeable scope to the full organization.

Key differences under the new 2023 model:

• Metric: Instead of counting specific users or CPU cores, you count all employees in the organization.
• Scope: One universal license covers all environments (no separate “desktop” or “server” licenses), but any use of Oracle Java triggers licensing for everyone.
• Legacy Renewals: Existing Java SE subscription customers on the old model may renew under the old terms only if they continue to use their licenses within the previously licensed usage. However, new purchases or expansions now fall under the employee-based scheme.
• Purpose: Oracle aims to ensure enterprises license Java broadly, closing loopholes where companies limited installations to reduce costs. The result is a much higher cost baseline for most organizations.

The New Employee-Based Java SE Subscription Model Explained

Oracle’s Java SE Universal Subscription uses an employee-count licensing metric. “Employee” is defined broadly, encompassing all full-time and part-time employees, as well as temporary staff, contractors, and consultants who support internal operations.

In essence, Oracle expects you to count everyone on your payroll (and relevant third parties) who could indirectly use or benefit from Java. Even if only a handful of people actively use Java, the license requirement extends to the entire employee population under this model.

How to count employees for Java licensing:

• Included: All full-time, part-time, and temporary employees in your organization, plus contractors and external consultants involved in your internal operations. This means that even non-IT staff are included, since they presumably use corporate computer systems (which may run Java).
• Excluded: Typically, third-party personnel who do not support your business operations (e.g., an outsourcer’s staff serving other clients). Only contractors dedicated to your company are counted, not the entire workforce of the contractor’s company.
• Unified Use Rights: With the subscription, any internal use of Oracle Java SE (across desktops, servers, or cloud) is permitted. There’s no need to track installations by machine, but you must procure enough licenses to cover your total employee count.

This model is “all or nothing.” If you use Oracle’s Java at all (beyond free public versions), you are expected to license every employee.

The only way to avoid licensing all employees is to eliminate Oracle JDK usage entirely from your environment (or stick strictly to free Java variants). This high bar for coverage is what makes the 2023 change so impactful.

Pricing Tiers and Cost Implications

Oracle’s employee-based Java subscription is sold on a tiered pricing model, where the cost per employee per month decreases with higher employee counts.

However, even with volume discounts, the total cost for large organizations is substantial. Below is the Oracle Java SE Universal Subscription price tier (list price) structure introduced in 2023:

Larger enterprises get a lower unit price, but because every employee counts, the total spend can be dramatically higher than the old model.

For example, under the new pricing, a company of 1,000 employees would pay roughly $12,000 per month (at $12/employee), which is $144,000 per year.

Importantly, these fees are recurring (subscription-based), not one-time, so this is an annual expense as long as you need Java support.

Real-world cost examples: Many organizations have reported sharp cost increases when comparing the legacy model to the 2023 model:

• Mid-size Company (250 employees, minimal Java use): Under the old model (counting actual Java users and processors), this company paid around $3,000 per year for Java SE subscriptions. Under the new employee-based model, the annual cost would be about $45,000 – a 15× increase in cost (despite only a small fraction of employees using Java).
• Large Enterprise (42,000 employees): This organization used to pay roughly $85,000 per year for Oracle Java (covering a specific number of servers and users). With 42,000 employees, the new model would cost approximately $2.65 million per year (42,000 × $5.25 × 12) – an increase of about 30 times the previous cost.

These examples illustrate the sticker shock enterprises face. Even organizations that extensively use Java will see higher costs.

For instance, a company with 250 Java users (on 250 desktops and multiple servers) saw their annual Java licensing cost double, from ~$22k under the old model to $45k under the new model – even when every employee was already a Java user, the new flat per-head pricing was more expensive.

The bottom line is that Oracle’s 2023 licensing change can significantly inflate IT budgets, especially for companies with large headcounts or those who previously limited Java licensing to specific systems.

Illustration: Oracle’s 2023 shift to per-employee Java licensing led to an explosive increase in costs for many enterprises.

Impact and Risks for Enterprises

For enterprise IT leaders, Oracle’s Java licensing change in 2023 is not just a minor contract update – it’s a strategic budget and compliance issue.

Key impacts and risks include:

• Budget Shock: Many organizations must allocate drastically higher budgets for Java. Costs that were in the tens of thousands per year can jump to hundreds of thousands or even millions. This unplanned expense can strain IT budgets and requires executive attention. Companies that were running Java without a subscription (perhaps using older free versions) now face pressure to either pay up or risk running unsupported software.
• All-Employee Tax: The requirement to license every employee feels like a “tax” on the entire organization. Even employees who never directly use Java (e.g., HR staff) are still counted toward the license. This disproportionate model means organizations with limited Java usage are hit hardest relative to their usage. It also removes the incentive to minimize installations – one installation is enough to trigger licensing for all users.
• Compliance and Audit Risk: Oracle’s aggressive sales push has accompanied this change. There are reports of Oracle reps contacting organizations to ensure they “update” their Java licensing. The risk of software audits is heightened – Oracle now has a strong incentive to audit customers’ Java usage since any finding of Oracle Java in use could translate into licensing the entire company. Non-compliance could result in substantial back-bills or penalties.
• Existing Contracts in Limbo: Organizations that previously subscribed to Java SE (under Named User Plus or Processor metrics) have a temporary reprieve – Oracle has stated that these customers can renew under legacy terms if their usage remains unchanged. However, this is not guaranteed in the long term. When those contracts expire (typically on an annual basis), Oracle can require migration to the new model. In practice, unless you have contractual protections, you should assume that your next renewal will be on a per-employee pricing basis. This creates uncertainty and necessitates planning for a likely cost increase at renewal.
• Security vs. Cost Dilemma: Without a Java SE subscription (or an alternative support option), organizations won’t receive updates for critical security vulnerabilities on older Java versions. Oracle’s change essentially forces a choice: pay the subscription or keep using Java without updates (risking security), or attempt a migration to free alternatives. This “migrate or pay to stay” dynamic puts pressure on teams to either find budget for Oracle’s support or invest in moving off Oracle’s Java.

Overall, the 2023 licensing change has elevated Java from an afterthought to a top-line agenda item for IT asset management.

Enterprises must now treat Oracle Java similarly to how they manage database or ERP licenses – with careful tracking, compliance checks, and strategic decision-making – since the financial stakes are so much higher.

Strategies for Navigating the Change

Given the impact of Oracle’s Java licensing overhaul, IT leaders should proactively develop a strategy to manage both compliance and cost.

There are a few paths an organization can take:

• Assess and Optimize Java Usage: First, conduct an internal audit of where Oracle Java is used in your environment. Identify which applications and systems rely on Oracle’s Java distribution. You may find instances of Java that are not needed or that could be replaced. Eliminating unnecessary Oracle Java installations can reduce your exposure (in an ideal scenario, removing all Oracle Java would mean you don’t need any subscription).
• Consider Alternative Java Distributions: Oracle is not the only source of Java. Open-source builds (OpenJDK) and third-party supported Java distributions (from vendors such as Red Hat, Amazon Corretto, Azul, and IBM) are available. These alternatives implement the same Java standards and can often replace Oracle JDK with minimal change. Many are free or less expensive to license, and some vendors offer long-term support for older Java versions without the costs associated with Oracle. Migrating to a non-Oracle Java distribution can allow you to continue getting updates and support without needing to count all employees for Oracle licensing. (For example, some companies have switched to OpenJDK or Temurin builds to avoid Oracle fees.)
• Leverage Oracle’s Free Java Options Cautiously: Oracle now provides the latest Java versions under a No-Fee Terms and Conditions (NFTC) license. For example, Java 17 and Java 21 can be used in production for free until the next version is released. This can be a stopgap measure: if your organization can stay on the latest Java version and upgrade every six months, you can use Oracle’s JDK at no cost. However, this is challenging for many enterprises due to testing and compatibility. It also doesn’t provide long-term support – once a new version is released, the previous version’s free support ends. Use this approach only if you have a strategy to continuously upgrade or if you need time to transition to another solution.
• Review Contracts for Bundled Rights: Check your existing Oracle product licenses to see if you already have rights to use Java in certain contexts. For instance, some Oracle enterprise products (middleware, databases, etc.) include Java SE use as part of their license. If so, ensure you document those entitlements to defend against any Java licensing claim for those specific uses. This won’t cover all Java usage, but it might reduce the scope for which you need a separate Java subscription.
• Engage Oracle (or Partners) for Negotiation: If Oracle Java is mission-critical and you decide to purchase the Universal Subscription, approach Oracle proactively. There may be room to negotiate enterprise agreements, especially for very large organizations. Oracle’s published prices are high, but big customers might negotiate better rates or concessions (for example, bundling Java with other Oracle license deals). Ensure you understand your employee count definition clearly and have an internal consensus on that number before negotiating with Oracle. It’s also wise to involve a software licensing expert or advisor – Oracle’s contracts can be complex, and you want to avoid committing to terms that are unfavorable (like counting more employees than necessary or restrictive audit clauses).
• Plan for Audits and Compliance: Treat the Java subscription like any other major software compliance topic. Update your software asset management policies to include Java. Keep records of where Oracle Java is installed, and if you migrate some systems to other Java distributions, document that as well (to show auditors you’ve mitigated usage). Train your IT staff not to download Oracle JDK on a whim – uncontrolled installation could put you out of compliance. Given Oracle’s history of audits, being prepared is key. By having accurate data and making an informed decision (whether that involves licensing or migration), you can face Oracle’s inquiries with confidence.

By taking these steps, organizations can regain some control over the situation. The goal is to either minimize the need to pay Oracle’s Java tax or, if paying, ensure you’re only paying for what you truly need and at the best possible terms.

The next section provides concrete recommendations and actions for IT leaders to consider in light of the 2023 Java licensing changes.

Recommendations

• Inventory Your Java Deployments: Immediately identify all instances of Java in your enterprise (servers, applications, desktops). This will determine if you are using Oracle’s Java and the scope of coverage needed.
• Calculate the Impact: Determine your total employee headcount (including part-time and relevant contractors) and estimate the subscription cost for your organization. Use Oracle’s pricing tiers to project annual expenses. This data is crucial for budget planning and decision-making.
• Consider Migrating to Open-Source Java: If possible, avoid the Oracle subscription by uninstalling Oracle JDK and switching to open-source or third-party Java distributions. Assess the compatibility of your applications with OpenJDK or other vendor JDKs. Many enterprises have avoided new fees by migrating to alternatives that provide free updates (or more affordable support).
• Use the Latest Oracle JDK if Feasible: For organizations that can rapidly upgrade Java versions, leverage Oracle’s no-fee license on the latest release as a short-term measure. This can buy time while you plan a longer-term solution. Just be cautious – you must stay on the newest version continuously, which requires an agile update process.
• Audit-Proof Your Organization: Document Your Java Usage and Licensing Decisions. If you choose not to subscribe, ensure that no unauthorized Oracle JDK installations remain in use (replace them with alternatives). Train IT staff about the new rules so that well-meaning developers don’t inadvertently create a license obligation by downloading Oracle Java.
• Engage Vendor Management & Legal: Treat the Oracle Java subscription as a major contract. Involve your procurement and legal teams to review terms. If you must purchase, negotiate with Oracle on ambiguous terms, such as the exact employee count definition or potential flexibilities (especially if you’re near a pricing tier threshold).
• Evaluate Bundled Options: If you have Oracle products that include Java (e.g., WebLogic, Oracle applications), consult with Oracle to determine if those deployments are covered under your existing subscription. Ensure you’re not paying twice for Java in those instances.
• Plan for Renewal Changes: If you are an existing Oracle Java subscriber under the old model, use the remaining term of your current contract to plan for future changes. Evaluate now whether you will renew and accept the new model or opt for migrating away before the renewal date. Have a roadmap in place rather than waiting for a surprise at contract expiration.
• Monitor Updates and Further Changes: Oracle’s licensing policies are subject to change. Stay informed via Oracle’s announcements or industry news so you can adapt your Java strategy if, for example, Oracle introduces new free options or modifications to the employee count model.

Checklist: 5 Key Actions for Oracle Java Licensing 2023

1. Audit Your Java Usage: Compile a list of all applications and systems using Oracle’s Java.
2. Determine Your License Scope: Calculate your total employee count (including eligible contractors) that would need to be licensed under the new rules.
3. Estimate Your Costs: Project the annual cost for Java under Oracle’s 2023 pricing. Present this to leadership for budget awareness (it may be substantial).
4. Decide License vs. Alternative: Choose a path – either plan to purchase Oracle’s Java subscription for all employees, or initiate a migration to alternative Java platforms. (In many cases, the alternative route can save significant costs.)
5. Implement and Educate: Execute your plan. If subscribing, work with Oracle on a contract and ensure compliance tracking is maintained. If migrating, roll out the new Java runtimes and remove Oracle JDK installations. Educate your teams on the changes so there’s no confusion going forward.

FAQ

Q1: What exactly changed in Oracle’s Java licensing in 2023?
A: Oracle introduced a Java SE Universal Subscription that uses an employee-based metric. This replaced the old licensing (which was based on per-user or per-processor counts). Now, if you use Oracle Java, you must license every employee in your organization. The change took effect in January 2023 and immediately applied to new subscriptions and renewals (unless you were grandfathered under a prior agreement temporarily). Essentially, it’s a shift from licensing specific Java usage to licensing the entire company’s potential use of Java.

Q2: Do we have to pay for all employees even if only a few use Java?
A: Under the new Oracle model, yes – the license requirement is based on total headcount, not actual usage. Even if only 10 out of 5,000 employees use an Oracle JDK-based application, Oracle’s policy says you need to purchase 5,000 employee licenses. This can feel counterintuitive and unfair. The only way to avoid this is to eliminate Oracle Java from your environment, thereby eliminating the need for the subscription. Many companies are evaluating alternatives for this reason. If you continue using Oracle’s Java (for example, to get critical updates on an older version), Oracle expects an enterprise-wide subscription.

Q3: We have an existing Oracle Java subscription (previously purchased). Will we be forced into this new model?
A: Not immediately, but likely at your next renewal. Oracle has stated that customers with legacy Java SE subscriptions can renew under their existing terms if their usage hasn’t grown. In practice, this means if you have already licensed 100 users or 10 processors, you might be allowed to renew with those same numbers again for another term. However, if you need to increase coverage or once your contract term ends, Oracle will push you to transition to the employee-based model. It’s prudent to assume that the legacy model is a temporary option at best. You should prepare for the new model’s impact, as Oracle ultimately aims to transition all customers to the Universal Subscription. Always confirm with Oracle in writing what your renewal options are, and plan as if the older pricing might go away.

Q4: How can we reduce the cost or avoid paying Oracle’s Java subscription?
A: The primary way to avoid these new fees is to stop using Oracle’s Java distribution where possible. You can switch to open-source Java implementations (like the OpenJDK builds provided by other vendors). These are functionally equivalent to Oracle JDK for most applications. Another strategy is to upgrade to the latest Java version and use it under Oracle’s no-fee license (so you’re not paying as long as you keep updating to the newest release). Additionally, check if any of your Oracle software licenses already include Java – use those rights if applicable to cover certain uses. If using Oracle Java is non-negotiable (for example, some enterprise apps require it), consider negotiating a deal with Oracle or a third-party reseller, or explore whether a Java support provider (such as Azul or IBM) can offer a more favorable arrangement for support. The key is not to simply accept the first quote – explore alternatives and only pay Oracle if you absolutely must, and ideally with a well-negotiated contract.

Q5: What are the risks if we don’t address these licensing changes?
A: Ignoring the changes can lead to compliance liabilities and security risks. If Oracle conducts an audit and finds that you are using Oracle Java without the proper subscription, your company could be liable for backdated subscription fees for your entire employee count (potentially incurring a huge, unplanned cost), as well as possible penalties. It’s better to be proactive – either get compliant or remove the non-compliant software. Separately, suppose you choose not to subscribe and also not to update Java (to avoid fees). In that case, you risk running outdated Java versions with no security patches, which could leave your systems vulnerable to security threats. This can lead to security breaches or failure to comply with audits in other areas. In short, the risk of a large bill from Oracle and the cybersecurity implications mean the issue can’t be simply put off. It’s important to make a conscious decision on how you’ll handle Java going forward.

Read about our Java Advisory Services.

Would you like to discuss our Java Advisory Services with us?

Please enable JavaScript in your browser to complete this form.

Name *

First

Last

Email *

Company

Message *

Submit